Picaridin vs DEET — Which Bug Repellent Is Better?
Picaridin vs DEET – Which Bug Repellent Is Better?
- 1 Picaridin vs DEET – Which Bug Repellent Is Better?
- 2 Picaridin vs Deet
- 3 How Repellents keep ticks and mosquitoes of
- 4 What is Picaridin
- 5 Side effects of Picaridin
- 6 What is DEET
- 7 Side effects of DEET
- 8 Insect Repellent During Pregnancy
- 9 Picaridin vs DEET?
- 10 The Best Tick Repellent: Is There Anything More Effective than DEET?
- 11 The Best Tick Repellent According to the Scientists’ Opinions
- 12 Tick Repellents Active Ingredients Review: Is There Anything More Effective than DEET?
- 13 Active Ingredients of Tick Repellents: Advantages and Disadvantages
- 14 Top-18 Tick Repellents
- 14.1 Effective Tick Repellents for Humans, Tested For Years
- 14.2 Sawyer Products Premium Permethrin Clothing Tick Repellent Spray
- 14.3 Repel 94101 6-Ounce Sportsmen Max Insect Repellent 40-Percent DEET Spray
- 14.4 OFF! Deep Woods Insect Repellent 6 ounce (Pack of 2)
- 14.5 Repel 100 Insect Repellent, 4 oz. Spray
- 14.6 Sawyer Products Premium Insect Repellent with 20% Picaridin
- 14.7 Repel Lemon Eucalyptus Natural Insect Repellent, Spray
- 14.8 Best Tick Repellents for Dogs: a Collar, a Spray, Drops & Shampoos
- 14.9 Bayer Seresto Flea and Tick Collar for Dogs
- 14.10 Vet’s Best Flea & Tick Pet & Home Spray
- 14.11 Frontline Plus Flea and Tick Control for Dogs and Puppies
- 14.12 Bayer K9 Advantix II, Flea and Tick Control Treatment for Dogs
- 14.13 Hartz UltraGuard Rid Flea & Tick Shampoo for Dog with Oatmeal
- 14.14 Natural Tick Repellents: Sprays, Patches and a Pen
- 14.15 TICK BAN – YAYA Organics Tick Repellent
- 14.16 BioUD® Insect Repellent & Clothing Treatment Mini Trigger
- 14.17 Mosquito Patches Insect Repellent Deet Free
- 14.18 Tick Pesticide for the Yard
- 14.19 36.8 % Permethrin SFR 32 oz Tick Control Insecticide
- 15 Best Tick Repellents Comparative Chart
- 16 Is Natural Tick Repelling the Future or the Past?
- 17 What DEET Concentration Should You Choose?
This post contains affiliate links. If you click on a link and make a purchase I earn a commission at no extra cost for you .
The less you are bitten by ticks and mosquitoes, the lower the risk of becoming infected with tick-borne or mosquito-borne diseases. Effective protection against ticks and mosquito bites is best achieved with a combination of effective insect repellents combined with protective long-sleeved clothing.
Picaridin vs Deet
Insect repellents combine one or more repelling agents to keep bugs off. Two of the most effective substances that repel insects are Picaridin and DEET. They repel mosquitoes, ticks, and most other bloodsucking parasites and are used in different concentrations in many bug repellents.
Both substances are reliable and have been used for many years. However, as with anything that has an effect that is desired, there can sometimes also be undesired side effects that may even be harmful to your health. Read here what to consider using Picaridin vs DEET.
How Repellents keep ticks and mosquitoes of
Whether you use Picaridin vs DEET, both products work by forming a “protective shield” over the skin area of which they have been applied. Bloodsucking pests such as ticks, mosquitoes, black flies, horse flies can no longer smell you.
Most bloodsucking insects are attracted to their prey by the Carbon dioxide in the exhaled air, by smelly acids when sweat breaks down and at a short distance, they sense body heat. Effective repellents confuse the animals’ sensory organs so they no longer recognize and find their potential bite victim.
The protective effect against ticks lasts about four to five hours, depending on the concentration of the active ingredients, against mosquitos protection can last for as long as 8 to 10 hours. However, those are just estimates as there are many other factors that determine how long the protection lasts. Besides the concentration of the active ingredient, the actual amount applied, the type of insect, environmental factors such as temperature and humidity, and how much one sweats plays a role too.
What is Picaridin
Picaridin is a chemical compound from the group of piperidines. Picaridin is used as the active ingredient in many bug repellents to prevent bites and contracting infectious diseases.
It is effective against mosquitoes, ticks, sand flies, gnats, fleas, and many other insects.
Depending on the formula, repellents containing Picaridin provide protection for 8 to 10 hours against most mosquitos and up to 5 hours against ticks.
To humans, Picaridin is virtually odorless. It is non-greasy, does not attack plastics and generally considered to be well tolerated.
Side effects of Picaridin
Do not use products containing Picaridin if you have hypersensitivity to the active ingredient. This may show that after putting repellent on that contains Picaridin, the skin area begins to itch, redness may develop, or in very rare cases dry skin and flaking. However, side effects and skin irritation rarely occur in Picaridin, as the active substance is considered to be well tolerated even if used regularly.
When applying, take care not to get the product on open wounds or near mucous membranes. Be careful in the face too and avoid contact with eyes. If you use sprays, do not inhale the mist.
What is DEET
N, N-diethyl-m-toluamide – DEET for short – is a highly effective and reliable insect repellent.
It repels insects by irritating their senses so mosquitoes, sand flies, ticks can not sense the presence of humans.
DEET is well studied and its effectiveness is proven in 5 decades of use. trials. Protection depends on the concentration of the formula and is up to about 10 hours against mosquitoes and up to 5 hours against ticks.
In general, DEET is considered to be well-tolerated, it is used by millions of consumers annually. Adverse side effects are very rare but can be serious in some individuals.
Side effects of DEET
DEET is highly effective, it provides long-lasting protection and works against a wide range of biting insects. Its effectiveness comes at the price of a slightly higher risk of side effects.
In certain cases, DEET may cause skin irritation such as redness and a burning sensation. These side effects usually occur only with frequent use or especially with improper use of DEET. Sensory irritations such as tingling sensation and numbness have in rare cases been reported. This is due to the fact that DEET can be absorbed through the skin and can have unwanted side effects on the nervous system. In severe cases, DEET can cause seizures and brain damage.
However, when used according to the instructions, the EPA considers DEET safe to use to prevent tick and mosquito-borne diseases.
As the active substance irritates the eyes and the mucous membranes as well, it should not come into contact with them like picaridin.
Since DEET reacts with certain plastics and leather, it should not come into contact with items such as sunglasses, plastic bottles, leather shoes or bags, etc.
Insect Repellent During Pregnancy
As an expectant mother, protecting your baby is your top priority, so is the protection of your own health as this directly affects the baby. Some tick or mosquito-borne diseases can be a risk to pregnant women and the unborn baby. When using repellent to reduce the risk of such diseases you have to balance all Pros and Cons.
Studies on how the use of repellents affects the unborn are rare. This is no wonder because tests on pregnant women are critical for obvious reasons. Information is collected from animal experiments. The use of Picaridin has so far not shown any damaging effects. Using DEET when pregnant is of similar concern. There is not enough evidence yet, so this drug should also be used with great care.
During pregnancy, you should use products containing Picaridin or DEET only after consulting with your doctor and if you are at an increased risk. Find more information on the Centers for Diseases Control and the Environmental Working Group links about the uses of repellents.
Picaridin vs DEET?
Both Picaridin and DEET containing insect repellents provide reliable protection against ticks and mosquito bites and can reduce the risk of contraction diseases.
Picaridin is better tolerated by the body with potentially fewer side effects than DEET and may be considered as the drug of choice in malaria-free areas. Repellents using DEET have the advantage that their protective effect has been studied for longer and it is more about the product and its side effects. In areas prone to malaria, the use of DEET is often recommended because it is highly effective repealing all sorts of daytime and nighttime mosquitoes.
When comparing Picaridin vs DEET, it is hard to say if one is better than the other. Both are very effective in reppeling biting little creatures. But keep in mind, even the best insects repellents can not completely prevent tick and mosquito bites. Other measures such as bright, long clothes to cover up and mosquito nets when sleeping can help to keep annoying pests away.
The Best Tick Repellent: Is There Anything More Effective than DEET?
At the height of summer, it is advisable to think about precautions against tick bites, as these insects are most active on warm days. The consequences can be most severe, including borreliosis (Lyme disease), black fever, recurrent typhoid, tick-borne paralysis and tularemia. Untimely therapy can lead to disability or even death of the patient. In this article, you will learn which tick repellents are recommended by scientists, whether a natural tick repellent is worth buying, and which modern treatments will best protect you, your dog and your garden from ticks. Here you’ll find TOP-18 effective tick repellents: 10 natural and DEET repellents for humans, 5 repellents for dogs, an insect repellent for clothing & pesticide sprays for yard.
How to prevent tick bites? The general tips are as follows: avoid wooded areas, especially on the shady side, remove leaves and mow high grass near the house, wear light-colored clothes covering hands and feet as much as possible. All these tips are useful, but they do not provide real protection against bites.
Table of Contents:
The Best Tick Repellent According to the Scientists’ Opinions
How to prevent tick bites? The general tips are as follows: avoid wooded areas, especially on the shady side, remove leaves and mow high grass near the house, wear light-colored clothes covering hands and feet as much as possible. All these tips are useful, but they do not provide real protection against bites.
The scientists think that special tick repellents must be used against these parasites. They are supposed to be applied on skin or clothes and are sold in the form of lotions, creams, gels, aerosols. There are two types of repellents: traditional treatments containing synthetic chemicals and vegetative (or natural) repellents.
According to the information from the University of Arizona and CDC, the active ingredients of effective tick repellents are the same as those of mosquito repellents. “The Centers of Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recommend the use of products registered with the EPA: those containing DEET, picaridin, IR3535, and oil of lemon eucalyptus and para-menthane-diol products are well established as the most effective active ingredients of repellents.”
CDC recommends Permethrin as a repellent for clothes. It cannot be applied on skin so you should only treat clothes and such objects as a bed canopy with it.
EPA has found out that one-third of the USA population uses DEET-based repellents. They are popular, but are they the most effective commercial products? Are there any decent rivals? Below, we are going to examine the effectiveness of all of the above mentioned ingredients and pick the best products containing them. If you are already aware of this, scroll down to the top 18 Tick Repellents.
Tick Repellents Active Ingredients Review: Is There Anything More Effective than DEET?
Let’s examine in detail what the scientists have to say about the effectiveness and safety of various substances.
Picaridin, also known as KBR 3023, is a synthetic chemical considered to be effective by the USA Center for Disease Control and Prevention. This substance has been invented by the German Bayer AG in 1980s. It is an alternative to DEET and is widely used in Europe.
According to EPA’s Picaridin profile, it has a pleasant odor and does not leave any oil debris. Moreover, Picaridin is low-toxic and only a few cases of skin and eye mucous membrane irritation has been registered after contacting it.
If 5-10% concentration is used (which is acceptable for use on children over six months old), Picaridin’s action will last from 3.5 to 8 hours. To prolong the effect for up to 14 hours, opt for 20% concentration. Picaridin evaporates off the skin slower than DEET does and thus repels ticks for a longer period of time. In addition, the chemical does not destroy plastic.
Various tests conducted in 2004-2010 have shown that Picaridin’s effectiveness is equal to that of DEET’s, and the World Health Organization has even recommended using this chemical along with DEET against disease vectors.
Permethrin stands out in this list of chemicals. As the National Pesticide Information Center explains, the main difference lies in the fact that this substance not only repels ticks, but also kills them on contact. Permethrin is 2.250 times more toxic for ticks than for humans.
NB! Permethrin can only be applied on clothes! In no case should you ever apply it directly on your skin. It is the only pesticide approved by EPA for this. The fact that the US Military uses it to treat combat uniforms to protect the military from the disease vectors proves its effectiveness.
If applied properly, Permethrin molecules are tightly attached to fabric fibers, allowing the substance to stay intact even after washing. Moreover, only a small share of it reaches the skin and 1% of that penetrates your body. Permethrin is odorless and does not leave stains on clothes. Its effect will last for up to four weeks after each home treatment, even if you wash your clothes.
Susan Paskewitz, Prof. of Department of Entomology, University of Wisconsin-Madison has published research results where the test subjects who treated their clothes with Permethrin were bitten 3.36 times fewer than the focus group wearing untreated clothes. Knowing where to apply the repellent is also crucial as your protection will increase almost 73 times if you treat your shoes with permethrin!
IR3535 is a substance that has been used in Europe for deer ticks, mosquitoes, body lice, and biting flies repellent for almost 20 years. EPA claims that “Toxicity tests show that the IR3535 is not harmful when ingested, inhaled, or used on skin”. It is also considerably inferior to DEET in terms of effectiveness.
According to the University of Nebraska–Lincoln scientists, earlier research has shown that IR3535 is able to ensure protection from insects lasting for 4-6 hours, “…but another study performed at USDA laboratories found that 25% IR3535 was 10-100 times less effective than DEET.”
DEET. U.S. EPA has found out that one-third of the USA population uses DEET-repellents. They are considered highly effective and their action has been studied better than that of other repellents. The fact that DEET was synthesized over 70 years ago, i.e. much earlier than other substances, explains why it was examined much more thoroughly.
DEET acts not by killing ticks, but by minimizing their chance of smelling their victim. According to the EPA, initially, DEET was designed for the USA Military in 1946, and has become available in open retail sale since 1957.
Nowadays, over 120 products by 30 brands are registered officially. Despite abundant choice of various treatments based on picaridin and other ingredients, DEET will not give in and is still considered the best repellent. Below, we’ll elaborate on the peculiarities of using DEET-based repellents.
Oil of Lemon Eucalyptus is a trade name of a repelling action substance based on the Australian eucalyptus extract and looks 100% natural. However, according to the EPA, it cannot be considered natural as it is “for commercial use, the active ingredient is chemically synthesized.” The American Spectrum Brands sells products containing this substance under the brand names, Repel and Cutter. Although it can be a fierce competitor to DEET, if highly concentrated, it is inferior to it in terms of duration of tick protection.
Active Ingredients of Tick Repellents: Advantages and Disadvantages
|DEET||For humans, is to be applied on skin and clothes||Has been used for almost 70 years, is well-researched. Its effectiveness depends on concentration so you can find protection even in extreme conditions with plenty of insects. It is safe if used properly in moderate amount.||Does not kill ticks, only repels them. Can cause side effect if concentrated highly. Can damage certain surfaces (e.g. plastic). Is more useful against mosquitoes than ticks.|
|Picaridin||For humans, is to be applied on skin and clothes||Has been researched for almost 30 years. It does not smell and does not destroy the surfaces. Low-toxic, its effect lasts longer than that of DEET as it takes longer (up to 14 hours) to evaporate from the skin.||Does not kill ticks, only repels them.|
|Permethrin||For humans (to be applied on clothes only), dogs and garden)||Kills and repels ticks. It acts quickly, effectively and lasts long (for weeks, even after washing). It does not damage tissue or synthetic surfaces. It does not leave any smells on dry clothes.||Treated clothes require special handling. Is extremely toxic for fish, pollutes water. Use carefully near cats as it is extremely toxic for them as well.|
|IR3535||For humans, is to be applied on skin and clothes||Toxicity tests have shown that IR3535 is harmless if ingested, inhaled or applied on skin.||Is less effective than DEET and is the newest repelling substance (has been subject to research for less than 20 years).|
|Oil of Lemon Eucalyptus||For humans (to be applied on skin)||The most natural and safest chemical repellent.||Only repels ticks. Can compete with other chemical only if highly concentrated. Short-lasting effect.|
|2-Undecanone||For humans, is to be applied on skin and clothes, and dogs||A synthesized organic liquid that is considered safe.||Only repels ticks. Can compete with other chemicals only if highly concentrated. Short-lasting effect and strong odor.|
|Garlic Oil||For the garden||Repels ticks and allows decrease of their garden population 2x.||Limited repelling action: best effect seen after the first treatment. One-time control measure.|
|Mixed essential oils||For humans, dogs and garden||Natural and safe repellent.||Limited repelling action. Use carefully on dogs if it contains eugenol.|
|IC2 (rosemary oil)||For humans and garden||Natural and safe repellent.||Limited repelling action. Most helpful when combined with other active ingredients.|
|Nootkatone||For humans, dogs and garden||Natural substance that both repels and kills ticks. It is non-toxic to such an extent that it can even be ingested.||Nootkatone-based repellents are not openly available for retail sale.|
Top-18 Tick Repellents
Below, we will list products, tested by millions of users for years that are available online. For your convenience, we have classified them into effective products for humans tested for years, the same ones for dogs and new experimental natural repellents.
Effective Tick Repellents for Humans, Tested For Years
Sawyer Products Premium Permethrin Clothing Tick Repellent Spray
It contains 0.5% Permethrin, its effectiveness is equal to 100% DEET products. It repels ticks, chiggers, mites and mosquitoes. Remember that permethrin cannot be applied directly on skin, spray it on clothes only! Its action lasts for up to six weeks (or six washings). The product does not smell on dry clothes and does not leave stains. It is recommended for use when hunting, fishing or engaging in other outdoor activities. You can read over 3300 customer reviews to know more about using Sawyer Spray.
Repel 94101 6-Ounce Sportsmen Max Insect Repellent 40-Percent DEET Spray
Today. this is a #1 Best Seller in the Pest Repellents category on from Check current price. It contains 40% DEET and acts for eight hours. It repels not only ticks, but also mosquitoes, gnats, biting flies, chiggers and fleas. Apply Repel only on uncovered body parts and clothes, but never under clothes! Just like any other repellent, it should not be used immediately after showering when skin pores are wide open. In that case. DEET will penetrate skin easier and can cause irritation.
The users are satisfied with the repellent’s effectiveness and give it a high rating of 4.5 stars out of 5. They note that Repel Max gives them less worries when their kids go camping: “I purchased this product for my son. He goes camping quite frequently. He goes in heavily wooded areas also. Nor have I found any ticks on him. I am very pleased with this.”
OFF! Deep Woods Insect Repellent 6 ounce (Pack of 2)
This anti-insect and tick aerosol contains only 25% of DEET. The manufacturer claims that it also repels black flies, sand flies, chiggers, gnats, fleas and no-see-ums. The product description also mentioned that it acts for up to eight hours against mosquitoes. It is unclear from this description, how long its tick repelling effect lasts. In the comments sections, the users mention that the interval between sprayings is about two hours. That is why you will have to repeat sprayings according to the manual.
It can be applied both on skin and fabric (cotton, wool or nylon). The manufacturer recommends also spraying cuffs, socks and around other openings in outer clothing or better tick protection.
Repel 100 Insect Repellent, 4 oz. Spray
It repels mosquitoes, ticks, gnats, biting flies, chiggers, no-see-ums and fleas. It is suitable for extreme environment and its action lasts for up to 10 hours, thanks to its maximal possible DEET concentration of 98.11%. Such a powerful spray costs from Check current price.
Although such concentration is permitted by the US authorities, the experts are doubtful. Sharon I Gripp, Associate of Pesticide Group of the University of Pennsylvania, believes that opting for lower DEET concentration would be a wise decision. In Canada, for instance, it is forbidden to use any products containing over 30% of DEET on people.
However, if you need longest protection (in the tundra, woods or when hunting), this is your best choice. No bloodsucker will ever approach you if you use this effective spray, as the users confirm. You’ll find over 2300 helpful customer reviews.
Sawyer Products Premium Insect Repellent with 20% Picaridin
Sawyer manufactures a wide range of powerful repellents based on 20% picaridin. Such concentration lets the substance repell ticks and mosquitoes for up to 14 hours and for up to 8 hours biting flies, gnats, chiggers, and sand flies.
Why does it take so long? As we’ve mentioned above, picaridin evaporates off clothes and skin slowly (even slower than DEET). It is non-toxic and can be used for family protection. Out of the entire Sawyer with 20% Picaridin product line, we pick lotion that has the longest effect. You can buy either a small bottle or store a 0.5 gallon lotion dispenser.
Price of ½ gal: Check current price
Price of 4 ounce: Check current price.
Repel Lemon Eucalyptus Natural Insect Repellent, Spray
This is the most tried and tested repellent spray. Over the years it’s been sold, it has collected nearly 4000 customer reviews. Its active ingredient is 30% eucalyptus oil. A bottle promises to protect you from the bloodsuckers for up to six hours. Although few people use this Repel product for actually repelling ticks, the scientists confirm the effectiveness of eucalyptus oil against these insects. The users are also happy that this Repel spray is gentler than DEET.
Cutter Lemon Eucalyptus Insect Repellent from Check current price is similar to this spray. Their main characteristics are identical, but Repel is way more popular.
Let us remind you that the oil of lemon eucalyptus is the most natural repelling action chemical. It is not 100% organic as it is artificially synthesized to meet industrial needs. The CDC experts do not recommend using the oil of lemon eucalyptus on children under 3.
Best Tick Repellents for Dogs: a Collar, a Spray, Drops & Shampoos
It is your personal responsibility to protect your dog from ticks. They bite dogs as frequently as people and the fur makes it far more difficult to notice a bloodsucker. Dogs do not always react distinctly and can suffer in silence while ticks drink their blood. That is why you should use a tick repellent for dogs so you don’t need to check up on your pet after every walk. Pick what’s most convenient for you: a collar, a spray, drops or a shampoo.
Bayer Seresto Flea and Tick Collar for Dogs
This is a #1 Best Seller in the Dog Flea Collars category. It incredibly has over 7400 customer reviews! It kills ticks on contact and repels them, is convenient and water-resistant. Seresto contains two active ingredients: Imidacloprid (10%) and Flumethrin (4.5%). It acts against ticks and fleas for up to eight months and the customers claim that after using this collar, the ticks do not relapse for six months.
The vets recommend using this collar as a temporary protection. According to the scientists, it cannot be used for over six consecutive days. After that, the collar should be removed and you should either let your dog take a break or find a more powerful parasite repellent.
Vet’s Best Flea & Tick Pet & Home Spray
This spray’s active ingredients are peppermint oil and eugenol (clove oil extract). It is a fast-acting insecticide that is able to kill most parasites on contact. It is so popular that it’s firmly considered to be a #1 best -selling dog spray.
Bear in mind that even natural products, such as Vet’s Best, can cause irritation of your dog’s sensitive skin because it absorbs eugenol very well. So do not overuse the spray and watch your dog’s condition closely. The product can also be used to treat your backyard.
Frontline Plus Flea and Tick Control for Dogs and Puppies
These drops contain 9.8% fipronil and 8.8% s-methoprene (IGR). Fipronil is slow-acting poison that affects the parasites’ central nervous system. IGR breaks the tick development cycle. And promises to kill 100% of adult fleas on your pet within 18 hours and 100% of all ticks within 48 hours.
The drops should be applied on your dog’s withers. Three portions are supplied for providing protection from the insects for one month. Your pet can feel temporary irritation on the part of its skin where the drops have been applied, so you should watch its condition. The price for the drops varies depending on the dog’s weight as the manufacturer has developed options for all weight groups.
Fipronil has an average rating and the users’ opinions are contradictory. It is most often compared with the following drops by Bayer listed below.
Bayer K9 Advantix II, Flea and Tick Control Treatment for Dogs
These drops are extremely powerful as they contain 44% permethrin as well as imidacloprid and IGR (pyriproxyfen). They repel and kill bloodsuckers on contact. Similarly, apply them on the withers. Note that the product is extremely toxic for fish so never throw a used pack in water in order not to pollute it. These drops also cannot be used on cats as permethrin is lethal for them!
The users are satisfied which is proven by over 6300 customer reviews. “I don’t like putting harsh chemicals like this on my dogs but honestly, it’s the only darn thing that works.” If you follow the manual, you won’t do any harm to your dog. Try it out to feel the difference from your usual tick repellents for dogs.
Hartz UltraGuard Rid Flea & Tick Shampoo for Dog with Oatmeal
This shampoo with oatmeal not only kills ticks and fleas, but also softens your pet’s dry and irritated skin. 0.27% Phenothrin (which is a pyrethroid, permethrin’s “distant cousin”) is responsible for killing pests. The users confirm that Hartz is very user-friendly and allows the dogs to remain ticks-free for up to three weeks following the treatment. Regular shampoos have a short-term effect. Read more customer reviews on to make sure it is worth buying.
NB! This shampoo is gentler than drops, but due to containing pyrethroid, it is as dangerous for cats as permethrin is lethal! Remember, this repellent is only for dogs and not for cats!
Natural ingredient shampoo, Wahl Natural Pet Shampoo is more expensive, it costs Check current price. Its advantage is its vegetative ingredients, namely rosemary and peppermint. It protects your dog from ticks, but it is unclear as to what extent. Although the scientists assure that essential oils have repelling action, they are far less effective than chemicals.
Let’s move on from natural repellents for dogs to natural repellents for humans.
Natural Tick Repellents: Sprays, Patches and a Pen
TICK BAN – YAYA Organics Tick Repellent
What does a natural spray have to offer? First, its ingredients are soybean oil, essential oils of: rosemary, peppermint, Texas cedar wood, lemongrass, Himalayan cedar wood, lavender/lavandin, rose geranium, sweet marjoram. It has a pleasant grass smell.
Tick Ban promises to repel not only the subjects of this article, but also black flies, gnats, and other bugs. However, the duration of action is not mentioned on the product’s label. Although the scientists ensure that oil mixes tend to have repelling action, it is likely that it is short-term, so you’d better combine it with other control measures.
Let us now describe some experimental repellents containing 2-undecanone. Lab experiments have shown that its effectiveness is comparable to that of DEET-based treatments. However, it hasn’t been in use for long enough to make sure these repellents are 100% effective.
BioUD® Insect Repellent & Clothing Treatment Mini Trigger
BioUD spray’s only active ingredient is 2-undecanone. It has an average duration as it promises to repel mosquitoes for 4.5 hours and repel ticks for up to 2 hours. Repeat treatment is then required. It can also be sprayed on clothes for additional insurance.
BioUD consumers complain of the product’s strong smell. According to them, it is very difficult to get used it and you will not be able to wash it off on the first try. Some of the rare comments are positive, so you can use it to form your own opinion.
BioUD also manufacturers this repellent in the form of a pen available for Check current price. Get the same effect with enhanced convenience! It’s perfect for travelling as it will fit any pocket or bag.
Mosquito Patches Insect Repellent Deet Free
These insect patches are promoted as family protection. The repellent contains oils of citronella, lemon eucalyptus and 2-undecanone. The patches can be attached to your skin, clothes or anywhere. They are even suitable for newborns. Protection is activated by pressing on the patch; it will work for about 10 hours after this.
So far there isn’t much feedback, and the rating isn’t very high. However, you should definitely try using 24 patches for only Check current price. They are cut-rate, simple and appear safe. Surely, such protection will be useful.
Tick Pesticide for the Yard
Before we’ve mentioned that certain natural insecticides can be used to repel ticks in your yard. Remember that their effectiveness is insufficient in having a substantial impact on parasites. That is why in the spring, when these insects’ activity peaks, you should treat your yard with a tried and powerful chemical. Pick one that kills ticks on contact, such as concentrated permethrin which has both killing and repelling action.
36.8 % Permethrin SFR 32 oz Tick Control Insecticide
Here is a very powerful pest control insecticide containing 36.8% permethrin. A 32 oz bottle can be dissolved into 20 gallons of product and used for treating the outdoors area from various pests. The manufacturer targets not only ticks, but also ants, bees, fleas, aphids, beetles, termites, roaches, chiggers and over 70 other insects. This product has a high rating as over 90% of customers like it.
The users share that they use the dissolved insecticide to treat not only their yard, but also their clothes (concentration ratio is 50:1). Everyone is afraid of Lyme disease, so it’s better to be extra cautious. In addition, permethrin conveniently kills all undesired pests in the backyard and has long-lasting action. “Works great! We have a wooded yard and spraying 2-3 times over spring and summer rids our yard of nasty ticks and mosquitoes. Prior to using this, I was being eaten alive by mosquitoes every time I walked outside and our dogs were picking up ticks daily.” Read over 600 customer reviews on to learn more helpful information about using permethrin for tick control.
Best Tick Repellents Comparative Chart
|Product||Type||Active Ingredients||Tick Protection||Price|
|Sawyer Products Clothing Repellent|
Is Natural Tick Repelling the Future or the Past?
Traditional repellents are considered effective and safe if used properly, but not all users like them. Therefore, the scientists are engaged in the development of new products for repelling and killing ticks based on plants and fungi which are natural tick repellents. Such drugs are safer, but the duration of their action is generally shorter than that of chemical analogs. Natural ingredients are constantly being tested. These tests demonstrate their ability to compete with substances such as DEET, but often being competitive requires an increase in concentration.
Unfortunately, everything is still in the lab testing stage. Few products containing these ingredients are sold, and the ones that are available have too few real users’ reviews that do not allow drawing any conclusions or recommending them as a proper means of protection. Below, we’ll summarize these new substances but we won’t risk recommending any of them as reliable or effective. Find the products in our list of the Top-18 Tick Repellents.
Repellents containing such active ingredient as 2-undecanone, are made of Lycopersicon hirsutum (wild tomato) leaves and stem essential oils and scare off ticks. They are to be applied on skin and clothes. Lab tests show that the effectiveness of this product is not lower than that of DEET-based treatments (and in some cases its performance is even superior).
As the Department of Entomology of the University of North Carolina experts note, “BioUD with the active ingredient 2-undecanone, originally derived from wild tomato plants, is a new repellent recently registered by the US EPA. Repellent efficacy of BioUD (7.75% 2-undecanone) and DEET (98.11%) was examined in the laboratory using a choice test between repellent-treated and control filter paper surfaces for Amblyomma americanum, Dermacentor variabilis, and Ixodes scapularis. BioUD provided greater repellency against A. americanum and I. scapularis than DEET. No difference was found between BioUD and DEET against D. variabilis.”
Such active ingredient, as Garlic Oil is made of garlic oil and is used to treat lawns and gardens and allows reducing the tick population by 59%. Its effectiveness peaks on the initial treatment, and so the scientists recommend using it for short-term only. A mix of essential oils (rosemary, lemongrass, cedar, mint, thyme and geraniol) also has repellent action. Such a mix can be applied on human skin or sprayed in the garden.
The specialists from Maine Medical Center Research Institute have tested IC2 containing 10% of rosemary oil and compared it to the synthetic bifenthrin. Within two weeks after spraying the lot with IC2 and bifenthrin, no ticks have been found while the lot treated with still water contained plenty of ticks carrying borreliosis. The main advantage of the product based on rosemary oil over bifenthrin lies in its safety.
Nootkatone, distilled from the Alaska yellow cedar essential oil, herbs and citrus plants, not only repels, but also kills ticks. The tests have proven that these relatively low-concentrated organic ingredients can be a potential alternative to synthetic repellents, such as DEET. Metarhizium brunneum/ anisopliae is made of wild fungi, is also able to kill ticks, but unlike Nootkatone, it can only be used to treat gardens and lawns.
What DEET Concentration Should You Choose?
When choosing a repellent, pay attention to the specified concentration level. The concentration of DEET in commercial products (lotions, creams, gels, aerosols, sprays and napkins) varies from 4% to 100%.
For most adults, it is sufficient to use 10% to 35% DEET concentration in order to provide adequate protection in most cases.
As for children, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommends repellents with a lower concentration. “Insect repellents containing DEET with a concentration of 10 percent appear to be as safe as products with a concentration of 30 percent when used according to the directions on the product labels.”
Note that using highly concentrated DEET repellents does not guarantee better protection. Higher concentration only means a longer effect, so pick such a repellent taking into account your stay near ticks. Also, such treatments are suitable if your regular repellent evaporates too soon (i.e. if you sweat intensely, when the temperature is high and it is damp). As a rule, repellents work for 1-5 hours, depending on whether you sweat, rub your skin and the amount of repellent applied.
How Safe Is DEET?
DEET does not pose a threat to human health, including children, given the strict compliance with safety regulations. For 70 years of use of DEET, this chemical compound has been thoroughly examined. It consistently demonstrates good safety performance. Although DEET is absorbed into the skin, in case of ingestion, it will be immediately urinated.
Studies have shown that this substance does not accumulate in human or animal bodies. There are cases of diseases caused by DEET, but the reason for this was either improper or excessive and prolonged use of the repellent.
Nevertheless, in some cases, DEET can pose risk when in contact with human skin and eyes, when inhaled or ingested.
The substance can penetrate the lungs when sprayed near humans or in an enclosed space where the vapors remain for a few hours. You can accidentally swallow DEET if you don’t wash the treated hands before meals. Side effects have been recorded when DEET was applied on the skin underneath the clothes.
If DEET gets into your eyes, it can cause irritation, pain and tears. When it remains on your skin long enough, it can also cause irritation, redness and swelling. Ingestion of DEET causes diarrhea, nausea and vomiting. In rare cases it can cause seizures.
Other disadvantages of DEET include a distinct unpleasant odor and skin oiliness when used. It can also damage certain plastic objects, such as sunglasses.
How to Apply Repellents?
Consumers should follow manufacturers’ instructions so as not to do harm to their health. First of all, labels of the products made in the USA must bear EPA registration number where the letter A confirms that the repellent was approved by the Environment Protection Agency of the USA. Section B must list all of the active ingredients specifying their concentration.
Note that the DEET abbreviation is not usually used; instead its chemical name N,N-diethyl-m-toluamide will be stated. Section C will cover the use of the repellent (i.e. whether it can be applied on the skin or used indoors). Possible risks and precaution measures including first-aid can be found under the letter D.
However, there are some general safety rules for the chemicals of which the repellents are made. DEET can be applied directly on the skin or clothes. It is most effective to treat pants and other clothes worn below the waist that can come in contact with ticks. However, DEET can damage certain fabrics or objects (for instance, plastic ones). Children must not use highly concentrated DEET. Don’t apply DEET on your hands or other body parts that can touch your mouth as well as on any wounds or irritated skin. After use, rinse the treated areas well.
Be extremely cautious when using permethrin. As we have already mentioned, such products are aimed specifically at treating clothes and other objects. It’s crucial to follow safety rules and not treat clothes that you are wearing. Use this repellent outdoors or in well-ventilated but not windy spaces.
Hang the treated clothing outside and wear it only when it dries completely. Wash it separately from other outfits. Don’t use the spray near water or flowers. Although permethrin is harmless for dogs, never let your cat near the treated clothes.
Should You Treat Your Yard with Pesticide?
If you spend much time outdoors in the garden, take all the possible measures to protect yourself from tick bites. First, take out any trash, such as household waste and leaves, and mow high grass. Widen the sunlit area as much as possible and minimize the shade where ticks usually breed.
Then you should treat your lot with insecticides. They can kill and/or repel ticks. However, the USA Centers for Disease Control and Prevention warn that although special treatments generally reduce tick population, don’t rely solely on spraying insecticides in your garden to protect yourself from infections.
The best chemical pesticide sprays contain pyrethrin, permethrin and such insect growth regulators as pyriproxyfen и fenoxycarb. The manufacturers, however, supply more organic products trying to satisfy the demand for safer ingredients.
Certain chemicals that aren’t pesticides are also able to repel ticks. Garlic, for example, does not kill them, but repels them. Cedar oil is lethal for ticks. Experienced gardeners recommend combining it with garlic to maximize the effect. Remember, that the effectiveness of natural products is inferior to that of chemical ones.