Is a Bed-in-a-Box Right for You? Consumer Reports
Is a Bed-in-a-Box Right for You?
- 1 Is a Bed-in-a-Box Right for You?
- 2 CR investigates the pros and cons of ordering a new mattress from an online retailer
- 3 A Workaround for Comparison Shopping
- 4 Say Goodbye to ‘Try Before You Buy’
- 5 Making Your Mattress Feel at Home
- 6 Best Beds-in-a-Box From CR’s Ratings
- 7 Bedbugs are giving Airbnb users headaches… and itchy bites
- 8 Bedbugs without borders
- 9 A spreading problem
- 10 ‘Is anyone getting bit?’
- 11 New towels, late apology
CR investigates the pros and cons of ordering a new mattress from an online retailer
What’s so difficult about buying a mattress? If you have to ask, you haven’t shopped in a mattress store lately. In the quest for a perfect night’s sleep, shoppers schlep from one cavernous bedding store to another, confronted by row after row of overpriced mattresses and huckster sales folks who claim, “I have such a deal for you.”
Frustrated by this experience, a new breed of entrepreneurs is taking on the mattress industry with the promise of the perfect mattress at the perfect price—and no pesky salespeople. The catch? You have to order the mattress online, and it arrives on your doorstep compressed into a box the size of your coffee table. No store. No sales pitch. No kidding.
While Casper gets a lot of the credit for the concept, the bed-in-a-box was actually invented by a machinist from Johnson City, Tenn., in 2007, seven years before Casper launched. Bill Bradley, founder and CEO of Bed in a Box, built a machine that could compress and roll foam mattresses to a size small enough to fit in a shipping box. He trademarked the name and ran with it.
Bradley’s business (bedinabox.com) didn’t make that big a dent in an industry still dominated by long-established players like 1-800-Mattress and Mattress Firm. It wasn’t until Casper and early competitors like Tuft & Needle came on to the scene—sometimes backed by venture capital—that shoppers began to wonder: Should I really buy a mattress online?
“The idea of ordering a mattress online, the same way you make much smaller purchases, is still a novelty, even though it has been an option for several years,” says Claudette Ennis, the analyst who follows the mattress market for Consumer Reports. “Beds-in-a-box represent just a small part of the market today, but we’ve seen some pretty remarkable growth in this category.”
Most beds-in-a-box are foam, but some manufacturers have found inventive ways to cram innerspring and adjustable air mattresses into cartons, too.
To make the process as pain-free as possible, many bed-in-a-box firms offer free shipping, and generous trial periods—usually 100 days, sometimes longer—and return policies. (Policies may differ if the mattress is purchased from a third-party retailer, such as Amazon.) Compare that with Macy’s, where returns must be made within 60 days of purchase.
The success of major bed-in-a-box purveyors such as Casper, Leesa, and Tuft & Needle has inspired dozens of copycats. Industry sources report that the number of online mattress retailers is now approaching 200, and many are puffing up their marketing messages in an attempt to be heard above the din. “Goldilocks found the bed that’s just right, and now you can too,” Purple touts. “The internet’s most comfortable mattress,” Tuft & Needle declares. “Tirelessly engineered sleep products for your best rest,” Casper claims.
In short, they’re promising to make your sleep dreams come true. Our rigorous, scientific mattress testing and ratings will help you separate hype from reality and guide you to the choice that’s best for you.
Here, the best way to purchase and set up a bed-in-a-box:
A Workaround for Comparison Shopping
One of the most frustrating things about buying a mattress has long been how difficult manufacturers make it to comparison shop. Unlike products that have the same name or model number no matter where they’re sold (a Samsung Family Hub refrigerator, for example, or a Vitamix blender), mattress makers often give the same model different names depending on where it’s sold, making it almost impossible for a consumer to compare prices. (They might also make slight changes in construction or materials from one retailer to another.) So don’t expect a salesperson to be able to guide you to a comparable model.
Bed-in-a-box sellers have eliminated this frustration from the buying process by paring down the choices. Many of these companies sell just one mattress, betting that it will suit most sleepers. Our testing shows that in theory, at least, this approach can work.
“We’ve seen several bed-in-a-box mattresses come through the lab that perform consistently, at a level of Good to Excellent, for sleepers of every body size and sleeping style,” says Chris Regan, a test engineer who oversees CR’s mattress tests. In fact, the top-rated foam beds-in-a-box score Very Good or Excellent in our support tests for petite, average, and large and/or tall sleepers.
Say Goodbye to ‘Try Before You Buy’
CR has long advised readers to lie on a mattress in a store for at least 10 to 15 minutes before buying. We still consider this critical. Our most recent mattress survey showed that the longer people try out a mattress before buying it, the more likely they are to be satisfied with their purchase. Ordering online prevents this opportunity.
Certain companies have worked around this limitation by teaming up with walk-in retailers. For example, you can now try a Leesa mattress at West Elm and buy it there for the same price offered at leesa.com. Casper has twin-sized mattresses on display at Target that you can curl up on to see how comfortable they are.
A handful of the large bed-in-a-box companies have showrooms in large metropolitan areas, so if you’re interested in a different brand but you’re not ready to buy a mattress sight unseen, check the company’s website to see whether it has a showroom nearby. If it doesn’t, you can refer to our mattress ratings. Find your size and favorite sleep position, and note the models that provide adequate support for you—and for your sleeping partner.
Unlike mattresses sold at retail, which are usually marked up significantly and offer more price flexibility, bed-in-a-box mattresses are generally sold at a fixed price, making it difficult to haggle.
But there are other ways to save. Check the sellers’ websites for special offers such as a free pillow, and go to goodbed.com, which lists mattress discounts and coupons with savings of $50 and up. Plenty of bed-in-a-box firms offer discounts around the same holidays that traditional retailers do—Presidents Day, Labor Day, and Black Friday. Use a website’s customer-service chat feature to ask about coming promotions or discounts.
Making Your Mattress Feel at Home
Mattresses usually arrive a few days to a week after an order is placed. Although the cartons are compact (the queen-size Lull, for example, comes in a 19x19x43-inch box), they can be heavy, ranging from 60 to 150 pounds, and difficult for someone to wrangle alone.
Shipping is often free, but for an additional fee almost all of these companies offer white-glove delivery, similar to the services offered by a traditional retailer. Casper charges $75 to $100 to move a mattress into a bedroom and set it up, and an additional $50 to remove the old one.
A bed-in-a-box, which is usually foam, is compressed and rolled or folded (or both) before shipping. Most manufacturers recommend unboxing a new mattress within a month or two after it’s delivered. If you’re setting it up yourself, follow the steps outlined by the manufacturer. If you bought a bed frame or platform, put that together first.
Because it can be heavy and unwieldy when fully open, always take the mattress to the bedroom while it’s still in the box, Regan says. “Once you take it out of the box, put it on your box spring or platform before removing the plastic.” (See “Do You Need a Box Spring?” below.)
“Some will be wrapped in multiple layers of plastic; others have only one,” Regan says. “You can use scissors or a knife to open them, but take care not to puncture the mattress.”
Once the wrapping is removed, the mattress regains the volume that was lost when compressed for shipment. It can take a few minutes to a few hours for the mattress to regain its full shape.
The materials in new mattresses can give off an odor, some of which is caused by the breakdown of volatile organic compounds in the foam. “More research is needed to determine whether or not there are any chronic health risks from long-term exposure to VOCs in mattresses,” says Don Huber, CR’s director of product safety. “The odor should dissipate in a few hours or, at most, a few days. You may want to wait until the odor goes away to sleep on your new mattress.” Opening a window could help the odor dissipate more rapidly.
Best Beds-in-a-Box From CR’s Ratings
Our top-rated beds-in-a-box range from $795 to $1,500. In terms of performance, Overall Scores range from 77 to 85. Here, CR members can see ratings for three key performance tests: how well the mattress supports an average-sized person who sleeps either on her back or on her side, and stabilization (how much vibration is transmitted across the mattress.) Click on each mattress to see full ratings and reviews.
SERVICED APARTMENTS — BETTER THAN HOTELS!
Apartment Reservation Network is the oldest serviced apartment rental company, managing own apartments in Moscow, and partner network of apartments in St. Petersburg, Kiev, Odessa, Volgograd and Yalta . We offer only highest-quality apartments, with maid service, and guarantee actual apartment to look like its pictures on our site and match the description.
PRIVATE AND SAFE.
If you had never stayed at a serviced apartment instead of hotel before, consider our great alternative to overpriced hotels with limited privacy, comfort and flexibility. Booking serviced apartments , all centrally located and renovated to Western standards just makes a lot more sense.
LOTS OF FREE EXTRAS.
Not only do you get complete privacy, total security, all basic amenities you expect, but check additional services available in many of our guest rental apartments! Many of our luxury apartments feature Hi-Speed Internet, Unlimited International phone calling and Mobile phone rentals. We can help arrange city tours any city we have apartments in. Inexpensive airport transfers are also available in every one of our cities.
ABSOLUTELY BEST VALUE AND SERVICE.
You can be sure that reserving from Apartment Reservation Network gets you Top Western standards and service, 24-hour assistance from our local offices, absolutely the best value for your money and the same privacy and comfort as you would expect in your own house.
Last minute offers:
|prices from $80
In Moscow, Russia
— FREE Fast Unlimited Internet (Notebook computer with Wireless LAN adapter is required);
— FREE Satellite-channel TV;
— FREE Unlimited Calls to most countries in the world;
Bedbugs are giving Airbnb users headaches… and itchy bites
Waking up with bedbug bites can be a nightmare. It’s also a costly and traumatic problem for Airbnb guests and hosts.
Terri was fast asleep when her phone rang. It was midnight on a Tuesday in early May. Despite the hour, she answered the call because it was from a guest at her Airbnb rental. The news she got was alarming.
«I’ve been bitten by something,» Terri says the guest told her. «I think you have bedbugs.»
Terri, a retired federal agent, has been renting out her three-bedroom beachside condo in South Carolina for nearly two years. (CNET opted not to disclose her full name to spare her public scrutiny.) She’s what Airbnb calls a «superhost,» an experienced and highly rated property owner. Terri didn’t know where the bedbugs came from, but she was sure they hadn’t been there before her guest arrived. So she turned to Airbnb for help.
At first, the short-term rental service provided assistance. Terri spent three hours on the phone with the company that night trying to find new lodging for her guest and information on how to get rid of the little blood-sucking creatures . But then Airbnb went silent. After CNET informed Airbnb more than two months later that it was writing a story about what happened, the company contacted Terri. Airbnb acknowledged it mishandled the situation.
«We have an outstanding customer support team,» Ben Breit, Airbnb’s head of trust and safety communications for the Americas, said in an email. «But when our handling of an issue fails to meet the high standards we set for ourselves, we work hard to ensure it is not repeated.»
Terri’s tangle with bedbugs is just one of hundreds of creepy-crawly examples of the problem affecting the popular lodging service. Spend time on an Airbnb forum, Twitter or Reddit and you’ll see report after report of bedbugs, whose bites don’t spread disease but can leave itchy welts and cause allergic reactions. Some of the reports include photos of swollen arms and legs covered in dozens of red boil-like bumps. Property owners often say renters are the source of the unwanted visitors, while travelers — or guests, in Airbnb parlance — blame hosts for not keeping their properties clean. Both sides agree that Airbnb isn’t doing enough to fix the problem.
CNET spoke to eight people who dealt with bedbugs in Airbnb rentals within the last three years. All of them said Airbnb, which was founded in 2008, doesn’t seem to have a systematic procedure in place for handling outbreaks. And most said that while they eventually received some form of compensation from Airbnb, the company failed to provide adequate support.
«This is my first real issue with Airbnb,» says Dariele Blain, whose weekend away with friends went awry after she says the critters emerged at her Airbnb rental in Philadelphia. «But it’s such an egregious one that I don’t know if I’ll book with them again.»
Like other Silicon Valley unicorns — private companies with a high valuation — Airbnb is known for «disruption,» the idea of changing a service or product with technology to make it better. It’s turned the lodging industry on its head by getting regular people to use its platform to rent out rooms or entire homes to travelers. Airbnb’s service is now operating in almost every country on Earth and it has over 6 million listings for rent. That’s more rooms than the top five hotel chains combined.
For each rental, Airbnb typically gets a cut of between 14% and 20%. The company, which may go public this year, is currently valued at $31 billion.
Airbnb proponents say these short-term rentals help hosts make ends meet, while also bringing more visitors to cities where people can’t afford high-cost hotels. But its business model has also triggered unintended consequences. The company has been blamed for rising rent and reduced rental stock in many cities, including its hometown of San Francisco. And in the case of bedbugs, experts say Airbnb’s use of millions of independent hosts means that keeping a lid on the pest epidemic can be hard to do.
«The Airbnb concept leads to less control by the health authorities in general compared with more traditional hotel concepts,» says Bastiaan Meerburg, who runs the Dutch Pest & Wildlife Expertise Centre. «People subrent a room in their house to earn some money but do not know who will occupy it, which may lead to bedbug problems and a lot of costs to get rid of those again. Tourists also do not know what to expect.»
It’s unclear whether Airbnb’s bedbug problem is equivalent to hotels or other accommodations since it declined to provide any details about how limited or widespread an issue it is. For those cases it does have, Breit said the company will suspend the listing until «the host can provide evidence (i.e. from an exterminator) documenting that the issue has been fixed.»
But beyond that, when it comes to individual complaints from hosts and guests about bedbugs, Airbnb said in a July 2019 tweet that it handles such situations case by case.
Bedbugs without borders
After talking to Airbnb that night in May, Terri went into high gear. She managed to move her guest and get an exterminator into her condo the next morning.
The exterminator did a thorough search and found some full-grown bedbugs. But there were no nests, and Terri’s mattresses appeared free of the tell-tale black spots from bedbug feces. It didn’t appear to be an infestation, Terri says. The exterminator told her he believed the bedbugs were likely brought in by her guest (bedbugs can attach themselves to luggage while traveling, for instance). He wrote a report on his work, and Terri provided it to Airbnb.
Bedbugs are reddish-brown, apple seed-size creatures that are attracted to heat and the carbon dioxide people exhale, so they tend to bite while their victims are sleeping. Once a place is infested with the pests, they’re extremely hard to get rid of since they can survive up to three months without a blood meal. It can include multiple visits from exterminators, throwing away furniture and laundering everything on high heat to banish the bugs. This can take a financial and psychological toll on people.
An Airbnb guest says she took this photo of a bedbug crawling across a rental’s bedspread.
The insects were nearly eradicated after World War II but had a major resurgence around 2010. Since then, they’ve been found almost everywhere, including five-star hotels, cruise ships, movie theaters, libraries, subway cars, nightclubs and even jury rooms. It’s no surprise they’ve also been found in Airbnb rentals.
«The problem has been around since the Bible days and it’s not going away,» says Grant Schwarz, a Florida attorney who handles bedbug lawsuits in the US. «It’s not like being bit by mosquitos. It happens to you when you’re most comfortable and vulnerable — you’re lying in bed.»
Schwarz says he gets hundreds of calls a year from people who believe they got bedbugs in Airbnb rentals. He says he receives more calls during the summer because that’s when people travel the most.
While Airbnb didn’t provide numbers on how many complaints it receives about bedbugs, a look at help forums on its website brings up 230 results on the topic over the past three years. People in places from Auckland, New Zealand, to Madrid, Spain, to Kyoto, Japan, tell stories of dealing with the critters. For comparison, a search for «cockroaches» calls up 103 results and «missing key» brings up 139 results.
A handful of news stories about bedbug-infested Airbnb rentals have been published over the last few years. In one, a woman said she was «devoured by the bloodsucking insects» in a Los Angeles rental. In a Hollywood Airbnb, an entire family said it was bitten on their arms and faces and one of the rental’s mattresses was crawling with bugs and covered in blood stains.
Those stories sound similar to the scenarios people shared with CNET.
Blain says she rented a six-bedroom townhome in Philadelphia with 19 other people for her best friend’s birthday last month (the booking was made under her friend’s name). The plan was to stay for the weekend, cook a big dinner and spend time together. As soon as she arrived, expecting her friends to show up with all of their boxes of food, she went upstairs to check out the rooms.
«I looked at the bed and I saw something crawling,» she says. «I was like, ‘Is that what I think that is?'»
She immediately took photos and called Airbnb. Blain says the company confirmed it was a bedbug but told her it wouldn’t relocate the group to another Airbnb since they were then «at risk» of spreading the pests. Instead, Airbnb told them to book a hotel. After calling around for a couple of hours, Blain found a hotel that could accommodate the big group and that they could afford. They saved all of their receipts and Airbnb reimbursed them a few days later for everything, including their rental and hotel.
«There’s nothing in there [about] what to do if the house is not clean or if there’s bedbugs,» Blain says. «They need to be more proactive with stuff like that because it’s a public health issue.»
A spreading problem
When the bedbug population exploded nearly a decade ago, many of the reports were problems at hotels and motels. That type of lodging was considered a major culprit in the transmission of the insects, according to Michael Levy, an associate professor of epidemiology at the University of Pennsylvania. But that’s changed, he says.
Over the years, hotels have instituted policies for curbing bedbug transmission, such as leaving linen carts in the hallway during room cleaning and scheduling regular pest inspections.
Marriot, Best Western, Wyndham and IHG hotel chains didn’t return requests for comment on their bedbug policies. The American Hotel and Lodging Association, which includes those chains among its more than 25,000 members, says it’s partnered with the National Pest Management Association to create a series of workshops to educate hotels on bedbug inspection techniques and prevention tips. Now, 98% of hotels have at least one ongoing bedbug prevention program, according to a 2017 study by pest control operator Orkin.
«Hotels are for the most part on top of the problem,» Levy says. «As the epidemic has progressed, it’s gotten into people’s houses and that’s where it’s become entrenched.»
A 2018 report by National Pest Management Association, which represents more than 6,000 pest control operators, says single-family homes and apartments and condos — the types of properties most likely to be listed on Airbnb — are the chief places exterminators deal with bedbugs. A typical extermination costs between $1,000 and $2,500.
While Airbnb’s rental inventory provides unique options for travelers who want to steer clear of cookie-cutter hotel rooms, those millions of homes are managed under a basic set of requirements, like «accept reservation requests» and «avoid cancelling on guests.» Airbnb also suggests hosts provide a «clean and tidy space.» But in its terms of service, Airbnb says it has «no control over» any of its listings and «does not guarantee» the rentals’ «existence, quality, safety, suitability, or legality.»
When asked what Airbnb does to prevent the spread of bedbugs in its rentals, Breit directed CNET to the Community Standards posted on the company’s website. These standards don’t mention bedbugs specifically but do say «you should not keep unsecured weapons, disease risks, or dangerous animals in your listing.» Breit also said Airbnb takes bedbug complaints «seriously.»
Airbnb’s slogan is «belong anywhere.»
«We take bedbug complaints as seriously as we would any safety or cleanliness complaint,» Breit said. «And we appreciate when hosts or guests bring these types of issues to our attention so that we can improve and correct any problems.»
Aside from urging users to contact its customer support hotline and suspending a listing if bedbugs pop up, it’s hard to discern if Airbnb has a cohesive policy on what to do in those situations. When asked what the company’s policy is for situations in which a guest finds lodging uninhabitable due to bedbugs, Breit pointed CNET to Airbnb’s Safety Resources and Tips, Guest Refund Policy, Contact Us page, Trust and Safety portal, Community Standards, Standards and Expectations, Host Protection Insurance, Terms and Policies and Terms of Service. None of these documents mention bedbugs specifically.
Meanwhile, the company’s official customer support account responded to a question on Twitter about its bedbug policy on July 11, 2019, noting that it handles the issue on a case-by-case basis.
«As each case is handled differently within our policies, we can’t provide an exact solution,» @AirbnbHelp tweeted. «We do have a team available 24 hours a day to assist should this, or any other unexpected situation arise.»
Breit said on Tuesday that the information provided in the tweet 33 days ago is «incorrect.» When asked again about a bedbug policy in place, Breit referred to his earlier statement on taking complaints «seriously» and suspending a listing until the issue has been fixed.
CNET spoke to one traveler who got bedbugs at an Airbnb and was asked by the company to sign a nondisclosure agreement prohibiting discussion of the experience. The traveler signed the NDA and declined to be named or speak about what happened.
After CNET asked Airbnb about NDAs last month, the company’s legal department called CBS Interactive’s lawyers objecting to the use of anonymous sources (CNET is a brand of CBS Interactive, which is owned by CBS). When asked again last week if Airbnb has people sign NDAs in instances with bedbugs, Breit said, «No.»
Public health experts say disclosing bedbug situations is the best way to combat the spread of the insects. If people aren’t talking about the issue, it’s unlikely to get solved.
«For any situation, keeping people in the dark about bedbugs is going to aggravate it,» says Levy, the epidemiologist. «You don’t want your tenant or guest to be afraid to tell you about it.»
‘Is anyone getting bit?’
Sumaya Moallin, who’s from Minneapolis, began planning a trip to New York with two friends in 2018. They saved everything they had and booked an Airbnb rental in Brooklyn last month under her friend’s name.
«We got there at night,» Moallin says. «The first morning I was like, ‘Is anyone getting bit?'»
Her back, arms and legs were covered in welts. So she decided to examine the mattress. And when she lifted it up, she says, there were hundreds of bedbugs crawling underneath. Big ones were stuck on the pillow, she says.
«It was straight-up out of a movie,» Moallin says. «I was like, ‘I just want to get out of here.'»
Another Airbnb guest says she took this photo of a bedbug on the wall in her rental.
Because Moallin and her friends had spent all of their money on the Airbnb, they couldn’t afford to go anywhere else. When they called Airbnb, the company said it couldn’t relocate them to another rental because they were «too much of a risk,» she says. Airbnb told the group to book a hotel.
Moallin says the Airbnb representative told them hotels are «more equipped» to deal with bedbugs. Both Blain and Terri say Airbnb representatives told them the same thing.
After roughing it for two more nights at the infested rental, sleeping all together the last night in what they considered to be the cleanest bed, the group decided they couldn’t take it anymore. Moallin and her friends reluctantly called their parents for help and were able to pay for two nights at a hotel. Once the whole ordeal was through, Airbnb ended up partially reimbursing them for the Brooklyn rental — but not for the hotel, she says.
«We spent half of those days being eaten alive. We had to burn all of our clothes,» Moallin says. «Now I’m even terrified of hotels because they’re sending people there too.»
Kristina Pankus, who runs a bedbug inspection business in the US and Europe called Doggybug, does bedbug detection and prevention in hotels regularly. She also gets bedbug inspection calls for a handful of Airbnb rentals every week. Pankus confirmed that Airbnb blocks rental units until they’ve been treated. And once a unit is cleared, Pankus sends a certificate to Airbnb saying the problem has been handled.
«Airbnb does try and control the bedbug problems as much as they can,» Pankus says. «It’s not like having cockroaches, it’s much, much more difficult to treat. … It’s still very taboo. People don’t want to talk about it, and if it’s not treated correctly it can be a disaster.»
New towels, late apology
Terri was dead-set on avoiding such a disaster. Sickened by the fact the exterminator found even just a few bedbugs in her condo, she went to work deep-cleaning. After paying $1,600 for the exterminator and another $325 to have her mattresses encased, Terri paid $85 each to have her three neighbors’ condos inspected — just in case. She also bought new linens, bath towels, comforters, pillows and beach towels.
Airbnb initially said it would reimburse her for some of these costs. But every time she called the company, its mediators said her case was closed. Before publication of this article, Airbnb apologized to Terri and offered to let her keep all of the rental income from that May guest and another $655 for additional costs.
Now, with lessons learned, Terri has a bedbug inspector scheduled to check her condo every month. She says it’d be helpful if Airbnb told all of its hosts to do the same, as well as encase their mattresses. Neither of those suggestions are in the various online documents Airbnb highlighted for CNET. But, Terri says, those actions could help prevent the spread of the pests.
«Whenever you list your space, your condo, your house, your whatever, I wish Airbnb would tell you that bedbugs are a problem throughout the country,» Terri says about registering a property with the company. «They don’t ask you any questions. They’re just like, ‘Upload it,’ and that’s it.»
Illustrations by Robert Rodriguez.